Critiques please? :) *Giving away under Giveaways Thread*

Comments

• Kylie Sommer

  April 2013 173.173.39.36

  Rate from 1-10: 7<br>Best thing about graphic: I like the husky and the positioning of it:)<br>Worst thing about graphic: It's a bit blurry and I'm not a big fan of the pink.<br>What you would have done to this: I would have looked for better quality pictures and done away with the pink.<br>Would you buy it: No, but only because I have no need for it:)<br>How much you think it's worth: Maybe around 15k as is<br>Extra comments: Nice job with it!

  
  Training Kennel
  Main Kennel
• Silverwolf99

  April 2013 69.166.74.180

  Cecctl2 wrote:

  Rate from 1-10: 7<br>Best thing about graphic: I like the husky and the positioning of it:)<br>Worst thing about graphic: It's a bit blurry and I'm not a big fan of the pink.<br>What you would have done to this: I would have looked for better quality pictures and done away with the pink.<br>Would you buy it: No, but only because I have no need for it:)<br>How much you think it's worth: Maybe around 15k as is<br>Extra comments: Nice job with it!

  <br><br>Thanks! Do you know where I'd have the best chance selling this? Maybe i'll auction it. I too was a bit iffy about the pink, but I think this was either made for a contest and never entered, or it didn't win and this is the clean copy (No text). Your right about it being a little soft around the edges

  
• Kylie Sommer

  April 2013 173.173.39.36

  Svenska wrote:

  Cecctl2 wrote:

  Rate from 1-10: 7<br>Best thing about graphic: I like the husky and the positioning of it:)<br>Worst thing about graphic: It's a bit blurry and I'm not a big fan of the pink.<br>What you would have done to this: I would have looked for better quality pictures and done away with the pink.<br>Would you buy it: No, but only because I have no need for it:)<br>How much you think it's worth: Maybe around 15k as is<br>Extra comments: Nice job with it!

  <br><br>Thanks! Do you know where I'd have the best chance selling this? Maybe i'll auction it. I too was a bit iffy about the pink, but I think this was either made for a contest and never entered, or it didn't win and this is the clean copy (No text). Your right about it being a little soft around the edges

  <br><br><br>You could try auction:) That's usually where I see premades sell.

  
  Training Kennel
  Main Kennel
• Silverwolf99

  April 2013 69.166.74.180

  Thanks for the recommendation! But I don't want to hold an auction with this one, so I just decided to be generous and give it away .

  
• tarnish

  April 2013 76.188.12.63

  Critique Sheet<br>Rate from 1-10: 3<br>Best thing about graphic: You picked an interesting background.<br>Worst thing about graphic: Things are blurry and the dog is just pasted on. You can also see a rough outline of the dog so removing the dogs previous background wasn't too smooth.<br>What you would have done to this: Try and make the dog look like it fits -into- the background. The dog is sitting in the middle of a frozen river and it just seems a little odd. The whole thing isn't really cohesive.<br>Would you buy it: Probably not =( I dont buy graphics unless its banners.<br>How much you think it's worth: 5k<br>Extra comments: It's a good attempt if you are just starting . Try looking at guides and attempting to fit the dog more into the background like it belongs. Seriously, keep practicing =D I have a feeling you can grow tremendously. Keep at it! =DD

  
• ivybear93

  April 2013 125.239.224.207

  Rate from 1-10:4.5<br>Best thing about graphic:the background is a nice choice (i have a thing for snowy backgrounds)<br>Worst thing about graphic:its blurry<br>What you would have done to this:changed the dog it doesnt suit with its coloring and looks lost on the edge of the page, though maybe writting would help a bit<br>Would you buy it: yes, i buy everything<br>How much you think it's worth: 10k maybe more<br>Extra comments: its a nice peice of work or itc ould be with some work when you get better ill buy from you

  
  And i belive that half the time i am a wolf amoung the sheep gnawing at the wool over my eyes
• Silverwolf99

  April 2013 69.166.74.180

  Thanks for all of the critiques! I'm still taking more, so feel free to comment. Eventually, I'll redo the graphic(s) based on the critiques for each person, and see how good we can get it! I'll also try to post more graphics for critiquing

  
• tarnish

  April 2013 76.188.12.63

  Svenska wrote:

  Thanks for all of the critiques! I'm still taking more, so feel free to comment. Eventually, I'll redo the graphic(s) based on the critiques for each person, and see how good we can get it! I'll also try to post more graphics for critiquing

  <br><br>Wow excellent I'm glad you're open for critique and take it well. Not all people are able to do that. Since you are so open to it, I'm sure you will improve a lot.